Restoring the Sacred

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Andy McCarthy's Case Against Miranda


Andy McCarthy, the brilliant former federal prosecutor who successfully prosecuted Omar Abdel-Rahman, the Blind Sheikh, for the 1993 bombing of the (now gone) World Trade Center, has published a three part article in National Review Online (NRO) in which he makes his case for treating terrorists as enemy combatants bent on destroying America rather than as criminals who have violated our criminal statutes. The following Note is from the NRO website:

(Note: In Part I of this article, Andrew C. McCarthy showed how Miranda warnings grew from a procedural safeguard into an inviolable constitutional right. In Part II, he explained how judges and the Justice Department expanded this right to the point where it applied to terrorists captured abroad. ...In the final part, he describes how the odd couple of John McCain and Barack Obama have put the nation in great danger by turning the War on Terror into something resembling a police investigation.)

Here are the links to the three parts of the article:

http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=MDNiNDVhMmRkY2Y3MzBkYTJhZTVjMGM5ZTYwNTAxMGU=

http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=NGU3ODQ4Y2U3NzczY2FiNTQzMWU1YmI5NjhiMGJlMmM=

http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=YjJmNjlmNjYxNWYyZDIyMWZjMTgyOTE0ZDIyZTg4MjA=